AI visibility tools: Profound, Peec, Otterly, Semrush
AI visibility tools from Profound, Peec, Otterly and Semrush do one job. They run a list of prompts through ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and similar engines on a schedule, then report whether your brand was named, linked or missing. Pick the one that fits the team that will read the report. None of them changes what the engines say about you. That is work on your site and on the rest of the web.
What every AI visibility tracker does
The four products overlap more than their marketing suggests. Each one takes a set of prompts you give it (or suggests some), sends them to the engines, and records the answer. From that record you get how often your brand appears, which competitors appear next to it, and which sources the engine cited.
Answers change from one run to the next, so a single check tells you little. A tracker earns its fee by repeating the same prompts week after week and showing the trend.
Profound vs Peec, Otterly and Semrush
Semrush is an SEO suite that added AI tracking. If your team already lives in it, the AI data sits next to your rank tracking and keyword work, and nobody has to learn a new login. Profound, Peec and Otterly are dedicated products built around AI answers from the start. Going by their positioning, Profound is aimed at larger teams, while Peec and Otterly are lighter tools for smaller ones. Pricing and engine coverage change often, so read each vendor's current page before you decide.
When you compare Profound vs Peec or any other pair, these six questions separate them faster than a feature list:
| Question to ask | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Which engines are covered? | ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity each pull from different sources, and Google AI Overviews is a separate surface. |
| Can you write your own prompts? | Generated prompts are easy to set up. Your own buyer questions are the ones that match your sales. |
| Does it show cited sources? | The list of cited pages and sites tells you where to work next. |
| Does it run each prompt more than once? | One run is noise. Repeats show whether you are cited reliably. |
| Can you export the data? | You will want it in your own sheet next to GA4 and sales. |
| Does it handle local or product prompts? | Store and location queries behave differently from software queries. |
How to test AI visibility tools in one week
Most of these products offer a trial or a demo. Spend the trial on a fixed test.
- Write 25 prompts a real buyer would type, including some where you expect to be missing.
- Load the same 25 into two tools.
- Compare the results with a manual check in ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity on a handful of them.
- Note which tool shows cited sources most clearly and exports cleanly.
We use 25 agreed buyer prompts when we measure clients, and we count a brand as cited when it is named or linked in at least 2 of 3 runs. That rule is easy to copy in a spreadsheet, and it stops one lucky answer from looking like progress. The audit page explains how we set the panel.
What no AI visibility tool will fix
A tracker shows you the red cells and leaves the fixing to you. The SOCi Local Visibility Index 2026 found ChatGPT recommends 1.2% of multi-location businesses, Gemini 11% and Perplexity 7.4%. If you run locations, the tool will report that you are missing, and the fix sits in your listings: Gemini grounds local answers on Google Maps, while ChatGPT and Perplexity use Bing Places and Yelp.
For everyone else, Ahrefs studied 75,000 brands and found third-party brand mentions correlate 0.66 with AI Overview visibility, against 0.22 for backlinks. A dashboard cannot earn you those mentions. Someone has to get your name into articles, directories and comparison pages that engines already read, and to publish answer-first pages on your own site.
The scoreboard still matters, because it tells you where to start. Our first customer, JCS Fashions, a Shopify apparel store, went from 20 sessions from AI assistants in January 2026 to 569 in October, with 5 AI-assistant orders in October. Citations came from the tracker, visits from GA4, and orders from Shopify.
Which one to pick
If you already pay for Semrush and want a first look, turn on its AI tracking and see what it shows. If AI answers are a priority for a bigger team that needs deeper reporting, trial Profound and one lighter tool side by side. If a small team wants the cheapest steady scoreboard, Peec or Otterly is the likelier fit once it passes the trial test above.
Whichever you choose, put someone in charge of acting on the output. The comparison of monitoring tools, agencies and apps lays out what each option leaves on your desk. To see where you stand before you buy anything, run the free AI visibility scan.